Sweet, creamy, and thick, this 1920’s inspired Stovetop Rice Custard is a vintage recipe keeper! An easy stovetop dessert that you’ll want to make again and again.
Custard is a food that has been around forever…well, the sweet pudding-like version has been around since at least the Middle Ages. [note]http://www.foodtimeline.org/foodpuddings.html [/note]
The simple ingredients of milk and egg are the key ingredients that make a custard a custard. Custards can be thick and savory (a mouthwatering bacon and cheddar quiche) or thin and sweet (a delicate silky-sweet creme anglaise).
It’s super versatile and there are so many different recipes for it throughout history.
Today’s recipe comes from the Picayune Creole Cook Book, just like last week’s hog head cheese!
I had Gramps look through the Picayune Creole Cook Book and along with the hog head cheese, this rice custard recipe stood out to him. His grandmother used to make it for him and he remembered loving it.
So, being the amazing granddaughter I am, I whipped up the Rice Custard recipe from the book.
There was only one problem…the ingredients didn’t list any eggs, but the directions did. This is actually a common problem with vintage and historical recipes. Either from little editing or the audience was trained cooks who were expected to know basic cooking skills, steps and ingredients were often left out.
Luckily for me, I had my lovely Gramps with me. He is a fantastic cook so I trusted him to guide me in the correct direction with the amount of eggs needed in this Stovetop Rice Custard.
“Use two eggs,” he distractedly yelled into the kitchen while he and my 13-year-old brother watched Macklemore’s “Downtown” music video (if you haven’t watched it yet, you must!).
I used two eggs, popped the thick rice custard mixture into the fridge and when we ate it the next day…it was delicious, but not as thick as Gramps remembered it. Everything else was on point, the sweetness, the orange flavor, all wonderful…it just needed to be thicker.
When I retested this vintage Rice Custard recipe, I added another egg and it was perfect. Gramps wasn’t with me for the retest, but I definitely will be making it for him again. When I do I’ll let you all know if the consistency is exactly how he remembers.
TIPS
Don’t rinse the rice before cooking! Rinsing removes starch from the rice, but you want to keep all that starchy goodness to help with the creaminess factor in this recipe.
Want to learn more about the types of custards? Awesome! Check out Crafty Baking for a great breakdown.
Wondering why I tell you all to whisk some of the hot cream into the egg mixture? It’s called tempering, and Claire from The Kitchy Kitchen has a great video explaining it in her 10 Second Living series.
Print
Prep Time:
Yield:
Print
PinDescription
Sweet, creamy, and thick, this 1920’s inspired Stovetop Rice Custard is a vintage recipe keeper! An easy stovetop dessert that you’ll want to make again and again.
Ingredients
- 1 1/2 cup calrose rice (not rinsed)
- 3 cups water
- 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
- 2 cups heavy cream
- 3 large eggs
- 1/2 cup sugar
- 1 teaspoon minced orange peel
- 1/2 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1/4 nutmeg, freshly grated (plus extra for garnish)
Instructions
- Combine rice, water, and salt in a medium pot. Cover, bring to a boil and reduce to a simmer. Cook, covered, until water has been absorbed and rice is very soft, about 15 minutes.
- While the rice cooks, whisk eggs, sugar, orange peel, vanilla extract, and nutmeg together in a large bowl until foamy and pale yellow.
- Once rice is fully cooked and most of the water is absorbed, stir in the heavy cream. Return to a boil then reduce to a simmer.
- Slowly pour a ladleful, about 1/2 cup, of the hot rice and cream into the egg mixture while constantly whisking. Repeat as needed until the egg mixture is close to the same temperature as the rice and add it to the pot.
- Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly and making sure to scrape the sides and bottom of the pot, until the custard has thickened and coats the back of your spoon, about 15 minutes.
- Transfer to a large bowl or eight 4-ounce ramekins and refrigerate for at least 8 hours before serving. Before serving top with a little extra freshly grated nutmeg.
Notes
Adapted from the [u]Picayune Creole Cook Book[/u]
I have been making Indian rice pudding for years. I use cinnamon sticks, ginger and ground cardamon. I also use full cream milk and condensed milk. I have never included eggs. It has always turned out excellent.
This time I am going to try it and include eggs and orange. I love all the spices in it. Do you think the orange will blend well with the flavour of the cardamom.
I think that cardamom would be delicious in with the flavors of this recipe. Cardamom and orange go really well together. Let me know how you like it!
Anxious to try this. I’ve been looking for a “vintage” rice recipe and have been repeatedly disappointed. My grandma used to make it for me but no recipe…just a grab and dash cook. She didn’t add the orange peel but would add cinnamon and raisins. Must try it both ways!
What a great recipe and your video was the best. Thanks!
Thank you!
I used to make a recipe almost identical to this one for a restaurant I worked in, but also added a generous amount of cinnamon to it and coated with cinnamon as well. It was outstanding and everyone loved it. I wonder if that was part of the reason that this did not turn out exactly as remembered? I have to make this now. We are getting unseasonable cool weather where I am and I feel this might make things better!
Carol, your version with the cinnamon sounds lovely!
Did you have a chance to make it?
Believe it or not when I went to make to make this recipe I discovered that I was out of rice!!!!!!?? Not too likely that this happens. Usually I have more than enough of everything in stock in my pantries.I see the reason for this is because I cannot find normal short grain rice that I like to use in my supermarket.So I will look again for the rice when I go shopping next.I look forward to making this!
That is too funny Carol! I hope you found the rice you needed and had a chance to make it this week! <3
This was so magical! When I snuck my first taste while it was still cooking, I about fainted and immediately vowed to myself that I’d never buy pre-made rice pudding again. My only problem was after it was done cooking and had chilled, it seemed like the heavy cream had become a little too *whipped*, if that makes any sense at all. I think I’ll make this again and try either not cooking (stirring) it as long, or perhaps sub while milk??? But I am blown away by what the orange peel adds to the richness of this recipe. Just WOW. Thanks for this fantastic vintage find!
Oh Erin!
I’m so excited that you made and love this recipe!
Your note about the cream feeling a little too *whipped* is not something I’ve had an issue with, but I totally understand it. I definitely think that maybe cooking a little less would help solve that problem and so would using whole milk!
Please let me know how it goes the next time you make it, and again, thank you trying it!!!
I LOVE rice pudding but hardly ever make it. I’ve never seen it w/ orange in it so I’m definitely going to have to try this. Plus I have Cajun roots, so that seals the deal.
Yay! I hope you have a chance to make it. My grandpa said that he always had his rice pudding with orange so I had to make it that way!
I love vintage recipes and this looks delicious! My grandmother used to make something like this but called it rice pudding.
So glad to hear you love vintage recipes! My grandma always made tapioca pudding, and this recipe also reminds me of it 🙂
Rice pudding is a wonderful comfort food. I love trying rice puddings and custards from different places. Always good and the subtle differences in them make it always exciting.This recipe is great…vintage bowls for a vintage recipe!
It really does make for a great comfort food, doesn’t it! Thanks, the vintage bowls are my step-mom’s, and she kindly let me borrow them for these photos 🙂
Such memories of this rice custard. I love your little bowls! Thank you for sharing this recipe!!
Any time! The little bowls are my stepmom’s 🙂 They are so fun!
Looks beautiful